One of the questions I’m asked most often is whether I recommend retirement plan providers to clients. The answer is yes—but probably not for the reasons many providers think.
The first thing I look for isn’t price. It isn’t technology. It isn’t even the size of the organization. I want to know whether the provider makes my client’s life easier or more complicated.
A good provider understands that every retirement plan is different. They know when to pick up the phone instead of sending another automated email. They recognize unusual compliance issues and aren’t afraid to ask questions before making assumptions.
Communication matters. If I have to chase someone for an answer, I begin to wonder how they treat their clients. If they respond thoughtfully, explain their reasoning, and admit when they need additional research, they earn credibility.
I also pay attention to whether they educate or simply sell. Providers who consistently publish useful content, speak at industry conferences, and share practical compliance guidance demonstrate that they care about improving the industry—not just increasing revenue.
Perhaps most importantly, I value providers who own their mistakes. Every organization makes them. The difference is whether the provider immediately develops a solution or spends time looking for someone else to blame.
ERISA attorneys remember experiences, both good and bad. We remember who returned calls during a crisis, who solved difficult operational problems, and who remained calm when deadlines became stressful.
If you want more referrals from attorneys, don’t spend your time telling us how great your company is. Show us through competence, communication, integrity, and consistent execution. Those qualities are remembered long after the sales presentation ends.