On a client call the other day, we were knee-deep in the usual chaos that comes with transitioning to a new TPA, mapping plan provisions, reconciling documents, and making sure the new prototype plan doesn\u2019t trip over the old one. These calls are a blend of ERISA minutiae and emotional endurance tests.<\/p>\n
Then came the sticking point: the automatic enrollment percentage. The old plan defaulted participants at 1%, but the new TPA\u2019s system didn\u2019t like anything under 3%. HR hesitated. \u201cWe\u2019ve always done 1%. I\u2019m not sure our employees will go for 3%.\u201d<\/p>\n
That\u2019s when I said it: you know your employees better than anyone, even better than an ERISA attorney.<\/p>\n
Automatic enrollment isn\u2019t just a checkbox in a plan document; it\u2019s behavioral finance in action. Whether the number starts at 1% or 3% changes how people view saving. One feels like a token effort, the other like a meaningful start. But culture matters, and no one understands the culture of a company better than the people inside it.<\/p>\n
Sometimes, plan design comes down to principle. You pick your hills. For me, this one was worth dying on, not because of 1% or 3%, but because ownership matters. A plan sponsor who listens to their workforce and stands by what works for them? That\u2019s fiduciary leadership in its purest form.<\/p>\n
At the end of the day, TPAs, attorneys, and recordkeepers all provide structure and compliance. But the sponsor is the heart of the plan. You know your people, their fears, habits, and paychecks, better than any spreadsheet or prototype document.<\/p>\n
And that\u2019s why, when it comes to the right default percentage, the real answer isn\u2019t in ERISA Section 404(c). It\u2019s in the breakroom conversations, the payroll deductions, and the quiet trust between employer and employee. That\u2019s the hill I\u2019ll always stand on.<\/p>\n
<\/span><\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":" On a client call the other day, we were knee-deep in the usual chaos that comes with transitioning to a new TPA, mapping plan provisions, reconciling documents, and making sure the new prototype plan doesn\u2019t trip over the old one. … Continue reading