I love Bitcoin. I love private equity. They\u2019re two of my favorite investments, personally. But when it comes to 401(k) plan participants? I hate them. Not because the asset classes themselves are bad, they\u2019re not. But because plan participants, by and large, make classic investing mistakes that alternative assets can make even worse.<\/p>\n
Let me explain.<\/p>\n
When you give everyday plan participants access to high-risk, low-liquidity investments, you\u2019re handing a loaded gun to someone who thinks the safety\u2019s on because the brochure said \u201cdiversification.\u201d Most participants already struggle with things like chasing returns, buying high after something\u2019s made headlines, and bailing out after a dip, locking in losses. They don\u2019t understand time horizons, liquidity constraints, or what a capital call even is. And now we\u2019re going to toss them the keys to private equity and Bitcoin in their retirement accounts?<\/p>\n
The new Trump executive order that \u201cbroadens access to alternative assets in 401(k) plans\u201d might look like a win for diversification and freedom of choice. And for a sophisticated investor with a financial advisor and a long investment horizon, it might be. But let\u2019s not kid ourselves: most participants aren\u2019t calling the shots with long-term strategy in mind. They\u2019re reacting. They\u2019re panicking. They\u2019re following headlines, not fundamentals.<\/p>\n
This isn\u2019t about being a gatekeeper. It\u2019s about being a fiduciary.<\/p>\n
As a fiduciary, I have to ask: is this in the best interest of the participants, or is it a win for asset managers who see a new pool of capital to dip into? Because if it\u2019s the latter, and it feels like the latter, then shame on us. Plan sponsors shouldn\u2019t chase the flavor of the month or cave to pressure from providers who see dollar signs instead of people.<\/p>\n
Alternative investments have their place. But for most participants, that place is outside their 401(k). Let\u2019s not confuse optionality with responsibility.<\/p>\n
<\/span><\/p>","protected":false},"excerpt":{"rendered":" I love Bitcoin. I love private equity. They\u2019re two of my favorite investments, personally. But when it comes to 401(k) plan participants? I hate them. Not because the asset classes themselves are bad, they\u2019re not. But because plan participants, by … Continue reading